A piece of charcoal and a piece of shining steel of the same surface area are kept for a long time in an open lawn in bright sun.
A. The steel will absorb more heat than the charcoal.
B. The temperature of the steel will be higher than that of the charcoal.
C. If both are picked up by bare hands, the steel will be felt hotter than the charcoal.
D. If the two are picked up from the lawn and kept in a cold chamber, the charcoal will lose heat at a faster rate than the steel.
Steel is a good conductor of heat whereas charcoal isn’t. So, the sunlight falling on the steel surface will make the surface hot and since charcoal is an absorber the incident sunlight would be absorbed by the charcoal. Since charcoal is bad conductor of heat, it won’t be too hot. Therefore, if both are picked up by bare hands, the steel will be felt hotter than the charcoal.
Secondly, Blackbodies are good absorbers of radiation and hence good emitters of radiation. Charcoal is a black body and thus it is a good emitter compared to steel. Hence, If the two are picked up from the lawn and kept in a cold chamber, the charcoal will lose heat at a faster rate than the steel.
Option (a) is incorrect as steel is a bad absorber of heat compared to charcoal as charcoal is a blackbody.
Option (b) is incorrect as temperature is the intensity of heat present in the substance. Steel is hot at the surface but charcoal has more heat intensity absorbed within it.
Thus, options (c) and (d) are the correct options.
Rate this question :
Cloudy nights are warmer than the nights with clean sky. Explain.HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
Two identical metal balls one at T1 = 300 K and the other at T2 = 600 K are kept at a distance of 1m in vacuum. Will the temperatures equalize by radiation? Will the rate of heat gained by the colder sphere be proportional to as may be expected from the Stefan’s law?HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
On a cold winter night you are asked to sit on a chair. Would you like to choose a metal chair or a wooden chair? Both are kept in the same lawn and are at the same temperature.HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
On a hot summer day we want to cool our room by opening the refrigerator door and closing all the windows and doors. Will the process work?HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
Standing in the sun is more pleasant on a cold winter day than standing in shade. Is the temperature of air in the sun considerably higher than that of the air in shade?HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
The temperature of the atmosphere at a high altitude is around 500°C. Yet an animal there would freeze to death and not boil. Explain.HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
An ordinary electric fan does not cool the air, still it gives comfort in summer. Explain.HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
A heated body emits radiation which has maximum intensity near the frequency v0. The emissivity of the material is 0.5. If the absolute temperature of the body is doubled.HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
A hot liquid is kept in a big room. The logarithm of the numerical value of the temperature difference between the liquid and the room is plotted against time. The plot will be very nearly.HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2
Why does blowing over a spoonful of hot tea cools it? Does evaporation play a role? Does radiation play a role?HC Verma - Concepts of Physics Part 2